Transliteration:( Faqaalooo a' basharan minnaa waahidan nattabi'uhooo innaa izal lafee dalaalinw wa su'ur )
"And they said: 'Shall we follow a man from amongst us? Surely we will be in error and insane.'"
In the Holy Qur'aan, a Prophet is often referred to as a human being, either by Allah Almighty, the Prophet himself, or by the disbelievers. If anyone currently calls the Prophet a mere human being, then they are not aligned with the understanding of Allah or the Prophet, but are instead in the category of disbelievers.
Hazrat Saleh (AS) had told his people that if they did not obey him, they would be foolish and misguided. However, the people of Thamud arrogantly responded that following him would make them devoid of intelligence, considering themselves to be right in rejecting him.
The tafsir of Surah Qamar verse 24 by Ibn Kathir is unavailable here.
Please refer to Surah Qamar ayat 23 which provides the complete commentary from verse 23 through 32.
(54:24) saying: “Are we to follow a single mortal,[17] one from among ourselves? If we do that, we shall surely be in error and folly.
17. In other words, there were three reasons for their refusal to obey and follow the Prophet Salih:
(1) He is a human being and not a super-human person so that we may regard him as superior to ourselves.
(2) He is a member of our own nation, he is in no way superior to us.
(3) He is a single man, one from among ourselves. He is not a prominent chief with a large following, or an army of soldiers. Or a host of attendants so that we may acknowledge his superiority. They wanted that a Prophet should either be a superman, or if he be a common man, he should not have been born in their own land and nation, but should have descended from above, or sent from another land, and if nothing else, he should at least have been a rich man, whose extraordinary splendor should make the people believe why Allah had selected him alone for the leadership of the nation. This same was the error of ignorance in which the disbelievers of Makkah were involved. They also refused to acknowledge the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) as a Prophet on the basis that he was a man who moved about in the streets like the common men, had been born among them only the other day and now was claiming that God had appointed him as a Prophet.
[1582]- i.e., the prophet Ṣāliḥ.
Related Ayat(Verses)/Topics